Downtown Denver skyline with the Front Range in the background

the City and County of Denver · Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists

Denver Uninsured Motorist Accident Lawyers

Denver uninsured motorist accident lawyers for crashes on Colfax Avenue, Federal Boulevard, I-25, and I-70. Free consultation. No fee unless we recover for you.

60+years combined experience
the City and County of Denverlocal crash evidence
Denver, COnearest firm office
No feeunless we recover for you

Denver UM/UIM Claims: Proving Fault in Denver District Court

McCormick & Murphy are Denver uninsured motorist accident lawyers for people hurt by a driver with no insurance or too little insurance. We get the Denver Police Department or Colorado State Patrol report, the Denver Health records, and file in Denver District Court.

An uninsured motorist claim is a first-party claim against your own policy, but it requires the same proof of fault and injury that a third-party claim does. You must show that the other driver caused the crash and that you suffered real, documented losses. The insurance company then evaluates your claim and either pays or denies it. If the offer falls short or liability is disputed, the case may go to arbitration or trial in Denver District Court.

Underinsured motorist coverage applies when the at-fault driver has insurance, but their liability limits do not cover all your damages. Your UIM coverage fills that gap. Both UM and UIM claims require careful documentation of police reports, medical records, wage loss, property damage, and any other economic and non-economic losses you have sustained.

From the Denver Police Report to Denver Health Medical Records

We obtain the crash report from the Denver Police Department or Colorado State Patrol, identify and interview witnesses, collect photographs and vehicle damage documentation, and secure your medical records and bills from Denver Health Medical Center and other providers. We also pull your insurance policy to confirm coverage limits, deductibles, and any stacking options that may apply.

We calculate lost wages, document pain and suffering through medical testimony, and review the carrier's file for any unjustified denials or low-ball offers. We also verify whether other insurance policies—homeowner's, renter's, or employer-provided—may provide additional coverage. This comprehensive record forms the foundation of our demand and any arbitration or court proceeding.

Investigating Denver UM/UIM Claims & Client Office Access

McCormick & Murphy are Denver uninsured motorist accident lawyers who obtain Denver Police Department and Colorado State Patrol reports, secure Denver Health medical records, and file in Denver District Court when you're hurt by a driver with no insurance or too little insurance.

  • Local crash evidence: We obtain the crash report from the Denver Police Department or Colorado State Patrol, identify and interview witnesses, collect photographs and vehicle damage documentation, and secure your medical records and bills from Denver Health Medical Center and other providers.
  • Local Claim Coordination: We coordinate local investigation, medical records, and court filing from our nearest office, with home or hospital meetings when travel is difficult.
Evidence Checklist Denver UM/UIM Claim Evidence Checklist

Essential documentation to prove fault and damages in a Denver uninsured or underinsured motorist claim—from police reports to policy endorsements.

  • Denver Police Department or Colorado State Patrol crash report
  • Your UM/UIM policy and endorsements
  • Coverage letters and claim-file correspondence
  • Denver Health Medical Center records and bills
  • Medical records from all treating providers
  • Photographs and vehicle damage documentation
  • Witness statements and contact information
  • Lost wages and employment documentation
  • Recorded statements and submissions to insurer
  • Insurer delay or denial explanations
  • Complete timeline from first notice of claim
  • Property damage repair estimates or total-loss valuation
  • Documentation of pain and suffering through medical testimony

Contact us as soon as possible—time limits apply to UM/UIM claims in Colorado, and early investigation is critical.

Colfax Avenue, Federal Boulevard, I-25 and I-70: When UM/UIM Coverage Applies

Denver's high-traffic corridors—Colfax Avenue, Federal Boulevard, I-25, and I-70—are common sites of collisions involving uninsured motorists. Neighborhoods like Capitol Hill, Five Points, RiNo, Cherry Creek, and Highlands Ranch see frequent crashes where the responsible driver has no insurance or minimal coverage. Our office in Denver is centrally located and familiar with the patterns of these collisions and the local courts.

Whether your crash occurred on a busy street, a residential road, or the interstate, the legal process is the same: prove fault, document injury, and secure fair compensation. We handle the claim from notification through settlement or trial, managing every communication with your insurer and ensuring deadlines are met.

Official Denver hospital, report, crash-record, and court links →

Recovering Medical Bills, Lost Wages and Vehicle Damage After a Denver Crash

Physical Harm When You're Hit by an Uninsured Driver in Denver

Collisions with uninsured motorists on Denver's major corridors—I-25, I-70, Colfax, Federal Boulevard—produce the same range of injuries as any other crash. The difference is that your own insurance must cover your medical costs and lost wages. Understanding the types of harm you've sustained is the first step in proving the full scope of your damages to your carrier.

Spine and Neck Injuries from Impact

Impact trauma, even at moderate speeds, can injure the cervical spine or lumbar region. Whiplash occurs when your head snaps forward and back, straining soft tissue and ligaments. Some injuries appear days later. Medical imaging and ongoing physical therapy records become essential evidence in your UM claim, especially if the other driver's negligence caused the collision. Document all treatment, including emergency visits to Denver Health Medical Center and follow-up care.

Rib, Chest, and Respiratory Complications

Direct impact to the torso can fracture ribs, contuse lung tissue, or cause pneumothorax (collapsed lung). Chest wall injuries may limit your breathing and ability to work. These injuries often require imaging (X-rays or CT scans) and sometimes hospitalization. Your carrier will need medical records proving the injury was caused by the collision and that treatment was reasonable and necessary. Even if you recovered quickly, document the initial severity.

Traumatic Brain Injury and Concussion Symptoms

Head strikes during uninsured motorist collisions can cause concussion, diffuse axonal injury, or more severe TBI. Symptoms include headache, dizziness, memory problems, light sensitivity, and mood changes that may persist for weeks or months. Many TBIs are not immediately obvious. Seek neurological evaluation and baseline cognitive testing. Document all symptoms in your medical records and follow your doctor's restrictions. Your UM carrier must understand that TBI damages—lost work, reduced earning capacity, ongoing treatment—are real and compensable. See our brain injury page when concussion or TBI is part of the claim.

Fractures, Dislocations, and Joint Trauma

Bone fractures in the arm, leg, pelvis, or hand require surgery or immobilization and prolonged rehabilitation. Dislocations, especially of the shoulder or hip, may cause permanent instability. Orthopedic surgery, imaging, physical therapy, and time away from work all generate evidence of injury severity and causation. Keep all imaging reports, surgical notes, and therapy progress records. Your carrier needs this documentation to evaluate your claim fairly and understand your wage-loss period.

Essential Actions Following an Uninsured Motorist Collision in Denver

When an uninsured driver hits you on I-25, I-70, or any Denver street, your immediate steps protect both your safety and your claim. Because you must prove the other driver's fault—even though you're filing a first-party UM claim—gathering scene evidence and witness information is as critical as any third-party injury case.

  1. Call Denver Police Department or Colorado State Patrol and Stay Safe Move to a safe location if possible. Call 911 or the non-emergency line for the Denver Police Department (or Colorado State Patrol if on I-25 or I-70). Report the collision, provide your statement, and request the police report number. The police report documents the other driver's information, citations, and preliminary facts about fault. Obtain the responding officer's name and badge number. This official record is foundational proof of the collision and often supports your fault argument in your UM claim.
  2. Document the Other Driver's Proof of Insurance Status Ask the other driver for their insurance card and driver's license. If they claim to have no insurance—or their policy is cancelled or invalid—document this clearly. Record their name, phone, address, vehicle plate, VIN, and their words about coverage. If they admit they're uninsured, ask them to repeat this on video if safe. Take photos of their ID and their vehicle. This evidence establishes why you must pursue your UM coverage instead of a traditional third-party claim.
  3. Photograph the Scene, Damage, and All Vehicles Before leaving the scene, take wide and close-up photos of the crash site, road conditions, traffic signals, skid marks, and both vehicles' damage. Photograph the other driver's vehicle, license plate, and any visible damage patterns. Take photos of your injuries if visible. Capture the surrounding area—nearby businesses with security cameras, street signs, weather conditions. These images provide independent proof of fault, impact severity, and injury causation that supports your UM claim and counters any later disputes about how the collision occurred.
  4. Collect Witness Contact Information and Statements Ask nearby witnesses for their names, phone numbers, email addresses, and what they saw. Take brief written notes of their account or record a short audio message. Witnesses who saw the other driver's negligence—running a red light, speeding, distracted driving—strengthen your fault evidence. Have them describe the collision sequence and their initial impressions of fault. Because UM claims can become contentious, contemporaneous witness statements carry weight in your carrier's investigation.
  5. Seek Immediate Medical Evaluation, Even for Minor Symptoms Go to an urgent-care clinic, emergency room, or your primary doctor as soon as possible. Some collisions cause injuries that worsen over hours or days—concussion, spinal strain, internal bruising. Medical evaluation at Denver Health Medical Center or another provider creates a time-stamped record linking your injuries to the collision. Report all symptoms, pain locations, and mechanism of injury to the medical team. The medical record is critical proof in your UM claim; delays in seeking care can undermine your damages.
  6. Notify Your Own Insurance Carrier Without Delay Call your insurer immediately—do not wait. Report the collision, the other driver's uninsured status, and your injuries. Provide the police report number and other driver's information. Your carrier will assign a claims adjuster. Cooperate fully, but remember that you have the right to consult an attorney before giving a recorded statement. Early notice ensures your UM coverage is activated and your claim is properly tracked. Delays in notification can complicate your claim and potentially affect your benefits.

McCormick & Murphy can guide you through each of these steps and advocate with your insurer to ensure your UM claim is handled fairly.

Building Your UM Claim: Proving Fault and Damages

A UM (uninsured motorist) claim is a first-party insurance claim—you file against your own policy. However, you still must prove the other driver's fault for the collision and document every element of your damages. Your carrier's adjuster will scrutinize causation, medical necessity, and the reasonableness of charges. We help you organize the proof your carrier needs to fairly evaluate your claim.

  1. Establish the Other Driver's Negligence and Causation Your UM claim requires proof that the other driver was at fault—negligence caused the collision. Gather the police report, witness statements, scene photographs, and vehicle damage patterns. Consult accident-reconstruction experts if liability is contested (for example, if the other driver claims you caused the collision). Your carrier needs clear evidence that the other driver's conduct—speeding, running a light, distracted driving—created the collision. Without establishing fault, your UM benefits may be reduced or denied. We work to build a strong liability case within your UM claim.
  2. Compile All Medical Records and Treat Consistently Obtain complete records from every medical provider who treated you: emergency room, urgent care, primary doctor, orthopedic surgeon, neurologist, physical therapist, chiropractor, mental-health provider. Include imaging (X-rays, CT, MRI), lab results, operative reports, and progress notes. Seek consistent treatment according to your doctor's recommendations; gaps in care or failure to follow medical advice can undermine your damages claim. Your carrier will review this documentation to establish injury severity, treatment necessity, and expected recovery. Organized medical records demonstrate the full extent of your harm.
  3. Document Wage Loss and Reduced Earning Capacity Provide pay stubs, employer statements, tax returns, and time-off records showing lost income due to injury, medical appointments, and recovery. If your injury reduced your ability to work (lighter duty, reduced hours, job loss), gather evidence of that impact. For self-employed individuals, provide business records and accountant statements. If you have permanent limitations affecting future earning capacity, consider vocational or economic expert evaluation. Wage loss is a core component of UM damages, and your carrier must see proof of the financial impact of the collision.
  4. Review Your Policy and All Coverage Elections Obtain a copy of your auto insurance policy and carefully review the UM/UIM (uninsured/underinsured motorist) limits, any deductibles, and stacking provisions. Understand your policy's terms regarding offsets (whether prior settlements or no-fault benefits reduce your UM award), subrogation (your insurer's right to recover from the negligent driver), and any exclusions. If your policy allows coverage stacking across multiple vehicles or policies, your attorney can help maximize available benefits. Policy analysis ensures you pursue every dollar of coverage available to you.
  5. Gather Proof of All Non-Economic Damages Document pain, suffering, reduced quality of life, and emotional distress through medical notes, your own journals, and testimony from family and friends. If the injury caused scarring, disfigurement, or permanent limitations, photograph and describe them. Medical providers' notes about your functional restrictions—inability to exercise, sleep disruption, loss of hobbies—support non-economic damages. Your carrier must understand that injury damages extend beyond medical bills and wages. Thorough documentation of these intangible harms strengthens your claim's value.

We help our clients in Denver, Capitol Hill, Five Points, RiNo, Cherry Creek, and Highlands Ranch navigate their UM claims by organizing evidence, managing communications with the carrier, and ensuring all damages are accounted for in the final evaluation. Start with the auto-accident hub for related crash types, or our brain injury page when head trauma is involved.

Colorado Fault Law and UM Claim Strategy

Colorado follows a comparative-negligence standard. Even in a UM claim, if the investigation suggests you were partially at fault for the collision, your recovery may be reduced proportionally. For example, if you were 20% at fault, your UM award would be reduced by 20%. Your carrier's adjuster will investigate both drivers' conduct. This is why scene evidence, witness statements, and police findings are so important—they establish the other driver's negligence clearly and minimize any argument that you contributed to the collision. We work to ensure your carrier understands the full context of the other driver's fault.

Notice and timing matter in UM claims. While Colorado law generally allows three years from the date of injury to file suit in Denver District Court, early notification to your insurer activates your coverage and starts the claims process. If the uninsured driver is a government employee or the collision involves a public entity like the City and County of Denver, RTD, or CDOT, different notice rules may apply—some require notice within 182 days. These public-entity claims have tight deadlines and special procedures. We review your specific collision circumstances to identify any public-entity involvement and ensure compliance with all notice deadlines.

What clients say about McCormick & Murphy

Real outcomes and reviews. Check Google reviews for the office that serves Denver — and read client testimonials.

After I was hit by a drunk driver with no insurance, my own insurer refused UM benefits. McCormick & Murphy sued for uninsured motorist benefits and bad faith. A jury awarded me over $900,000.

C. O., Denver · UM / bad-faith verdict

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its facts, coverage, venue, and evidence.

Questions We Hear From Denver Clients About UM/UIM Claims

Do I need Denver uninsured motorist accident lawyers after a crash?

Call Denver uninsured motorist accident lawyers when you were hurt, fault is disputed, or an insurer delays, denies, or offers less than the medical bills. The Denver office is in Denver, CO.

What if the uninsured driver is judgment-proof?

That is exactly why you carry uninsured motorist coverage. Your UM policy protects you regardless of the other driver's financial status. We file a claim against your own insurance and prove the other driver's fault. The other driver's lack of assets does not reduce your right to compensation from your own carrier.

How long do I have to file a UM/UIM claim in Colorado?

Colorado law imposes a three-year statute of limitations for personal injury claims, but insurance policies often require written notice of the claim much sooner—sometimes within 30 to 90 days of the crash. Failing to meet the policy deadline can result in denial. We advise notifying your carrier immediately and consulting us right away to ensure compliance.

Will my insurance rates go up if I file a UM claim?

Using UM coverage after a hit-and-run does not mean you were at fault. Colorado restricts premium increases for not-at-fault accidents under C.R.S. § 10-4-628, and Division of Insurance rules restrict increases based on UM claim payments. General filed rate changes still happen industry-wide, but that is not the same as a surcharge for filing the UM claim.

How much does it cost to hire you for a UM/UIM claim?

We work on contingency. You pay no attorney's fee unless we recover money for you through settlement, arbitration, or judgment. If we recover, our fee comes from the proceeds—typically a percentage agreed upon in our contract. Court costs and investigation expenses are handled separately, and we discuss all fees upfront before you sign anything.

What if my insurance company denies my UM claim?

We file a lawsuit or demand arbitration in Denver District Court. Colorado law requires insurers to handle UM claims in good faith, and denial must be supported by evidence. We present the proof of the other driver's fault, your medical records, and your damages. If a jury trial is necessary, we are prepared to advocate for you in court.

Will my UM carrier accept fault findings from the police report?

Police reports document the officer's observations and preliminary fault findings, but they are not binding on insurance carriers. Your UM adjuster will review the police report as one piece of evidence. If the report clearly indicates the other driver's fault—citations issued, witness statements supporting your account—it strengthens your claim. However, the carrier conducts its own investigation. Scene photos, independent witnesses, and accident reconstruction may be needed if the other driver disputes fault or if the police report is ambiguous. We help ensure all available evidence supporting fault is presented to the carrier.

What happens if I disagree with the carrier's damages valuation?

If your UM carrier's settlement offer seems too low, you have options. Request a detailed written explanation of how the carrier calculated damages—medical expenses, wage loss, pain and suffering. Provide additional medical records, expert opinions, or vocational evidence to support higher damages. If you and the carrier cannot agree, arbitration is often required under UM policy language. Arbitration is a faster, less formal alternative to litigation where a neutral third party reviews both sides' evidence and renders a binding decision. We represent you in arbitration negotiations and can advocate for fair compensation aligned with your actual losses.

Can I sue the uninsured driver directly while pursuing my UM claim?

Yes, you can pursue both a UM claim and a direct lawsuit against the uninsured driver. However, there are coordination rules—your UM carrier may have subrogation rights, meaning they can recover part of what they pay you if you later collect from the negligent driver's personal assets or wages. Some policies require you to pursue the negligent driver before UM benefits fully apply. Your policy language and Colorado law determine the interaction. We manage both strategies to maximize your total recovery while respecting your carrier's rights under the policy.

If the other driver later purchases insurance, does that change my UM claim?

If the other driver obtains insurance coverage after the collision, your claim typically remains a UM claim under your own policy, not a third-party claim. However, if you discover insurance was in force at the time of the collision (and was simply not presented at the scene), you may be able to shift to a third-party claim, which often allows higher damages and attorney's fees. This distinction is important. Early investigation into the other driver's insurance history is critical. We investigate thoroughly to determine whether any coverage existed and structure your claim accordingly.

Nearest McCormick & Murphy office

Discuss Your Denver Uninsured Motorist Accident Case

Speak directly with an experienced injury attorney. Free consultation. No fee unless we win.