El Paso County · Rider Fault and Comparative Negligence
Old Colorado City Motorcycle Rider Fault Lawyers
Old Colorado City motorcycle rider fault lawyers for riders hurt in Old Colorado City. Free consultation. No fee unless we recover for you.
Blamed For The Crash? Old Colorado City Rider Fault Lawyers Push Back
McCormick & Murphy are Old Colorado City motorcycle rider fault lawyers for riders blamed for speed, lane position, or not being seen. We file in El Paso County Combined Courts.
After almost any motorcycle crash, the insurance company looks for a reason to blame the rider. On the streets around Old Colorado City, that usually means claims about speed on Colorado Avenue, lane position near U.S. Highway 24, or an argument that the rider wasn't visible to other drivers. These are arguments the adjuster is trained to raise, not established facts.
Colorado law allows fault to be shared between a rider and a driver. Under C.R.S. § 13‑21‑111, any recovery is reduced by the rider's own percentage of negligence, and recovery is barred if the rider's negligence is equal to or greater than the negligence of the person they're seeking recovery from. That means how fault gets allocated has a direct effect on what a rider can recover, which is exactly why insurers push hard on this point early.
We treat every fault argument the insurer raises as something to investigate, not something to accept. A claim of speeding or poor lane position has to be tested against the actual evidence from the scene, not just repeated because it appears in a report or an adjuster's notes.
Proving The Insurer's Fault Claim Wrong With Real Evidence
The police crash report is a starting point, not the final word on fault. Officers responding to a crash near 21st Street or 25th Street often write down what a driver told them without fully accounting for how motorcycles move through traffic, brake, or become visible at intersections. Physical evidence, skid marks, debris fields, and vehicle damage patterns can tell a different story than the narrative in the report.
Video from nearby businesses, dash cams, and witness accounts from people who were on Colorado Avenue or near Manitou Springs at the time can also contradict a driver's version of events. We look for this evidence before it disappears, because it's often the difference between an insurer's fault argument standing unchallenged and being disproven with facts.
- Photograph the bike, the road surface, and skid marks before anything is moved
- Get contact information for anyone who saw the crash happen
- Ask nearby businesses whether their cameras cover the crash location
- Avoid agreeing to any fault percentage before an investigation is done
- Keep records of your route, speed, and gear at the time of the crash
Where Colorado Avenue Meets U.S. Highway 24 In Old Colorado City
Old Colorado City sits along a stretch of roadway where local traffic on Colorado Avenue mixes with faster through-traffic near U.S. Highway 24. That mix creates exactly the kind of scene where insurers try to shift blame onto a motorcyclist for supposedly not being seen or moving too fast for conditions. Riders passing through on their way toward 21st Street, 25th Street, or Manitou Springs are frequently the ones facing these arguments after a crash.
Claims arising from crashes here are handled through the El Paso County Combined Courts, and injured riders are often treated at UCHealth Memorial Hospital Central. We work from our office at 929 W Colorado Ave to gather evidence quickly, before witness memories fade and video gets overwritten.
Colorado comparative negligence →
Old Colorado City motorcycle overview →
Rider-fault / comparative-negligence claims in Old Colorado City are part of our broader Colorado Springs motorcycle accident lawyers practice for El Paso County.
Investigating Old Colorado City Motorcycle Rider Fault Claims & Client Office Access
Old Colorado City motorcycle rider fault lawyers for riders blamed for speed, lane position, or visibility after a crash. We investigate fault claims with physical evidence from Colorado Avenue and U.S. Highway 24 before insurers close the file.
- El Paso County Local Crash Evidence: Physical evidence, skid marks, debris fields, and witness accounts from Colorado Avenue or near Manitou Springs can contradict a driver's version of events.
- 60+ Years Combined Experience: McCormick & Murphy treat every fault argument as something to investigate, not accept. Under Colorado comparative negligence law, how fault gets allocated has a direct effect on what a rider can recover, which is why insurers push hard on this point early.
- Office Access: Clients meet with our team at 929 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 ↗ — with home or hospital consultations available if severe injuries prevent travel.
What A Rider Fault Claim May Recover
- Medical expenses tied to the crash
- Lost income from time away from work
- Property damage to the motorcycle and gear
- Pain and suffering from the injuries sustained
- Reduced recovery if shared fault is found to apply
How Rider Fault Claims Lead to Injuries in Old Colorado City
When an insurer argues that you were speeding, positioned incorrectly in your lane, or not visible to other traffic, they are building a fault defense. That defense can minimize or eliminate compensation for your injuries—even when you are seriously hurt. We examine what actually caused the crash, not what the insurer claims.
Road Rash and Abrasion Injuries from Disputed Blame
If the insurer claims you were in the wrong position or traveling too fast, they may argue your own negligence contributed to the slide. Road rash across arms, legs, and torso can be severe and require skin grafts. We document the actual roadway conditions on Colorado Avenue and U.S. Highway 24 to show how fault was misassigned.
Spine and Internal Injuries When Speed Is Alleged
Insurers often point to speed as grounds to reduce your recovery. Spinal fractures, rib breaks, and organ bruising may result from impacts that had nothing to do with your velocity. We work with accident reconstruction specialists to separate the insurer's narrative from the physics of the crash.
Fractures and Joint Damage in Visibility Cases
When an insurer says you were not visible enough, they may imply the other driver bears no responsibility. Broken wrists, ankles, and shoulders from low-side crashes deserve full recovery. We use witness statements and video evidence to prove the other driver's duty to see and avoid you.
Head and Facial Trauma When Fault Is Contested
Even if you wore a helmet, facial fractures and traumatic brain injury can occur. Insurers may allege your lane position or speed caused the collision, reducing your claim value. UCHealth Memorial Hospital Central records and medical imaging show the true severity of impact injuries regardless of fault arguments.
What to Do Immediately After a Crash Where Fault Is Disputed
In Old Colorado City and surrounding areas of El Paso County, your first actions set the foundation for proving fault is not what the other driver or their insurer claims. Gather facts, not assumptions, in the minutes and hours after impact.
- Move to Safety and Call Law Enforcement If you can do so without worsening injury, move off the roadway on Colorado Avenue, 21st Street, 25th Street, or U.S. Highway 24. Call 911 to dispatch El Paso County law enforcement. The police report will document initial observations, though it does not determine fault.
- Photograph the Scene, Vehicle Positions, and Skid Marks Use your phone to capture photos of both motorcycles, the other vehicle, the roadway, any skid marks, traffic signals, lane markings, and road hazards. Take wide-angle shots showing the intersection or section of road where the crash occurred. These images often contradict the insurer's later narrative about speed or position.
- Record the Other Driver's Information and Witness Details Get the name, phone number, address, driver's license, and insurance details from the other driver. Obtain contact information from anyone who saw the crash, especially those in vehicles or storefronts along Manitou Springs or nearby. Witnesses are your strongest defense against blame placed on you.
- Seek Medical Attention and Preserve All Records Even if you feel okay, go to UCHealth Memorial Hospital Central or an urgent care clinic. Document every injury, no matter how minor it seems. Medical records create a timeline and objective evidence that the crash caused real harm, which supports your claim even if fault is disputed.
- Do Not Admit Fault or Agree to Any Settlement Do not tell the other driver, witnesses, or the insurer that the crash was your fault. Do not sign anything without legal review. Statements made at the scene can be used against you later. Insurers will cite casual remarks as admissions, even if they misrepresent what you meant.
- Contact McCormick & Murphy Before the Insurer Calls Early legal review protects your rights. We interview witnesses while memories are fresh, preserve evidence the insurer might ignore, and prevent you from making statements that weaken your position. The sooner we act, the more facts we can gather.
Comparative negligence in Colorado means your recovery can be reduced by your share of fault. It does not mean you have no case if the other driver also bears responsibility. We fight to prove the insurer's blame is unfounded, not inevitable.
Building Your Fault Defense and Recovery Claim
When an insurer alleges you were speeding, poorly positioned, or not visible, that claim must be investigated, not accepted. We build a counter-narrative based on physical evidence, witness testimony, and expert analysis to show where fault truly lies.
- Analyze the Police Report and Identify Inconsistencies The El Paso County Combined Courts can review the crash report, but the report does not decide fault. We examine the report for contradictions with photos, witness statements, and the roadway itself. If the report places blame on you for speed, we challenge it with accident reconstruction and physics.
- Obtain Video Evidence and Surveillance Footage Cameras at businesses, traffic lights, and nearby buildings on Colorado Avenue, U.S. Highway 24, and surrounding streets may have recorded the crash. We issue preservation letters and subpoenas to obtain this footage before it is deleted. Video often proves the insurer's narrative wrong.
- Retain an Accident Reconstruction Expert When speed or lane position is disputed, we hire engineers who analyze vehicle damage, skid marks, final resting positions, and physics to determine what actually happened. Their report rebuts the insurer's claims and supports your defense in settlement negotiations or court.
- Document Visibility and Environmental Factors If the insurer claims you were not visible, we examine lighting conditions, weather, road surface, sight lines, and the other driver's duty to look. Photos taken at the same time of day and weather conditions show whether visibility was truly an issue or whether the other driver simply failed to see you.
- Build a Comparative Negligence Argument Under Colorado Law Under C.R.S. § 13-21-111, we prove the other driver's negligence was greater than yours. Even if you bear some fault, recovery is allowed as long as the other driver's negligence is greater. We quantify both sides and demonstrate you are entitled to recovery reduced only by any true negligence you share.
Fault disputes are won with evidence, not arguments. We gather that evidence while it exists and present it in a way that shows the insurer's blame is a tactic, not truth. See the motorcycle hub for related claim types. Head injuries may connect to brain injury. Fatal cases may connect to wrongful death. Coverage disputes may connect to insurance bad faith.
Comparative Negligence and Rider Fault in Old Colorado City
Colorado's comparative negligence rule allows recovery even when you share fault, as long as the other driver's negligence is greater than yours. This means you do not need to prove you were zero-percent at fault to recover damages. Under C.R.S. § 13-21-111, your recovery is reduced by your share of negligence. However, if your negligence is as great as or greater than the other driver's negligence, recovery is barred entirely. The burden is on the insurer to prove your fault exceeded theirs, and that burden is high when you have strong evidence.
Insurers use fault allegations as leverage in settlement negotiations. They argue you were speeding on U.S. Highway 24, positioned unsafely in your lane on 21st Street, or not visible during daylight hours on Manitou Springs roads. These are factual claims, not settled law. We challenge each one with photographs, witness accounts, and expert testimony. The crash report is a starting point, not a conclusion. Video, physical evidence, and testimony often paint a very different picture of who was negligent and by how much.
What clients say about McCormick & Murphy
Real outcomes and reviews. Check Google reviews for the office that serves Old Colorado City — and read client testimonials.
A passenger suffered traumatic brain, neck, and back injuries in a Colorado Springs intersection collision. After the carrier refused a fair number, a jury awarded $295,000 including interest and costs.
El Paso County jury verdict
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its facts, coverage, venue, and evidence.
Your Old Colorado City Rider Fault Questions, Answered
Do I need Old Colorado City motorcycle rider fault lawyers after a crash?
Call Old Colorado City motorcycle rider fault lawyers when you were hurt, fault is disputed, or an insurer delays, denies, or offers less than the medical bills. The nearest office is at 929 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905.
What happens if the insurer says I was speeding?
That claim has to be backed by real evidence, not just an adjuster's assumption. We look at skid marks, witness statements, and any available video to see whether the speed claim actually holds up. A speeding allegation alone doesn't decide the outcome of your claim.
Can I still recover if I was partly at fault?
Under Colorado's comparative negligence law, you can still recover as long as your share of fault isn't equal to or greater than the other party's. Your recovery gets reduced by your percentage of fault, so the exact split matters. Our comparative-negligence guide explains how this rule works in more detail.
Does the police report decide who was at fault?
No. The report is one piece of evidence, but it isn't the final determination of fault. Officers don't always have full visibility into how a crash happened, especially involving a motorcycle, and physical evidence can tell a different story.
What if the insurer claims I wasn't visible to the other driver?
Visibility arguments are common but need to be checked against the actual road conditions, lighting, and positioning at the time of the crash. Witness accounts and video can either support or contradict that claim. We don't let an unverified visibility argument go unchallenged.
How do I protect myself against a fault argument right after a crash?
Document the scene as thoroughly as you can, including the road, your bike, and any visible skid marks or debris. Get names and contact information for witnesses before they leave. Avoid agreeing to any fault percentage with an adjuster before you've spoken with an attorney.
If the police report says I was speeding, does that mean I cannot recover?
No. The police report is one document, not a court judgment. We gather evidence to show your actual speed, the roadway conditions, sight lines, and whether speed was truly a factor. If the other driver also violated a traffic law or failed to yield, comparative negligence means you may still recover even if you were speeding, as long as their negligence was greater.
What if the other driver claims I was in the wrong lane?
Lane position is a factual question we investigate with photographs, witness statements, and sometimes video. If you were changing lanes, we examine whether you used a signal, checked your mirrors, and followed safe procedures. If the other driver failed to look or yield, their negligence may outweigh any position issue on your part.
How does comparative negligence work if both of us were at fault?
Under Colorado law, your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. If you are 20 percent at fault and the other driver is 80 percent at fault, you recover 80 percent of your damages. However, if you are 50 percent or more at fault, you recover nothing. We work to minimize your fault percentage and maximize the other driver's responsibility.
Can an insurer refuse to pay because of my alleged fault?
An insurer may refuse payment if they believe your fault exceeds the other driver's. That refusal is not final. We challenge it by gathering evidence, consulting experts, and presenting a clear comparative negligence argument. Many refused claims are reversed or settled fairly once we provide supporting documentation.
Nearest McCormick & Murphy office
Colorado Springs — Downtown
Discuss Your Old Colorado City Motorcycle Rider Fault Case
Speak directly with an experienced injury attorney. Free consultation. No fee unless we win.