Boulder County · Insurance bad faith
Lafayette Insurance Bad Faith Lawyers
When insurers deny or underpay valid claims in Lafayette, we investigate their handling and hold them accountable.
What Is Insurance Bad Faith?
Bad faith can occur when an insurer fails to handle your claim fairly and promptly. This is not simply a disagreement over coverage—it is a breach of the duty your insurer owes you the moment you pay premiums and submit a valid claim. Insurers must investigate thoroughly, communicate honestly, and make reasonable decisions based on the facts and the policy language.
In Lafayette and Boulder County, a first-party claim (one you file with your own insurer for uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, medical payments, or property damage) triggers a duty of good faith. Unreasonable delay, selective investigation, misrepresentation of policy terms, or ignoring evidence that supports your claim can all amount to bad faith. We examine whether the insurer's delay or denial was reasonable under the circumstances or whether it was driven by profit rather than policy obligations.
Evidence We Examine
The policy itself is the foundation. We review the exact language of your coverage, the conditions, and any exclusions the insurer claims apply. We also obtain and analyze the insurer's internal claim file through discovery—including coverage letters, reserves, claim notes, evaluations by adjusters and supervisors, and any recorded statements or medical reviews the company relied upon.
We build a complete timeline: when you filed the claim, when the insurer responded, what information you provided, what the insurer requested, what medical or wage documentation was submitted, and when or why the insurer paid, delayed, or denied benefits. We compare the insurer's stated reason for any denial against the evidence available to them at the time. If the insurer ignored favorable evidence, applied the wrong policy language, or simply sat on the file without explanation, that conduct may constitute bad faith.
Local investigations may involve Lafayette Police Department, policies covering Lafayette residents and disputes that may proceed in Boulder County Justice Center.
Insurance bad faith cases require proof of the insurer's unfair or unreasonable handling of your claim. Use this checklist to gather and preserve key evidence for your claim.
- Original insurance policy and all amendments or endorsements
- First notice of loss or claim submission form and date sent
- All written communications from the insurer, including emails, letters, and coverage decisions
- Recorded statements or sworn examinations given to the insurer
- Medical records, bills, and wage loss documentation you submitted to support the claim
- Coverage letters or denial letters with the insurer's stated reasons
- All payment records, including amounts paid and dates
- Internal insurer documents obtained during litigation (evaluations, reserves, investigation notes)
- Timeline documenting when you submitted each document and when the insurer responded
- Proof of delay—written requests for updates and responses (or lack thereof)
- Photographs or reports related to the underlying injury or loss
- Any third-party reports (police reports, medical evaluations, repair estimates) submitted to the insurer
- Correspondence showing you requested expedited handling or appealed a denial
- Your own notes or diary of communication attempts with the insurer
- Any expert opinions questioning the insurer's basis for delay or denial
Preserve all originals and copies. Do not destroy or alter any documents. If the claim involved a car accident on U.S. Highway 287, Baseline Road, or another local road, or if treatment occurred at Intermountain Health Good Samaritan Hospital, include those records and reports. File suit within the deadline applicable to your claim type and policy—insurance deadlines vary and litigation must begin within the statute of limitations.
Medical Evidence and Claims
If your claim involves medical payment benefits or uninsured motorist coverage for injury, the insurer must fairly evaluate medical reports, treatment records, and provider statements you submit. An insurer cannot simply reject medical evidence without a legitimate reason or without consulting qualified reviewers. We obtain copies of all medical records and bills the insurer received and compare them to the insurer's response.
We also look at whether the insurer required unreasonable medical documentation, delayed processing to frustrate your treatment, or cherry-picked opinions that contradicted more credible medical sources. If Intermountain Health Good Samaritan Hospital or other providers in the Lafayette area treated you and submitted their records promptly, an unjustified delay or denial by the insurer may show bad faith.
Official Lafayette hospital, report, crash-record, and court links →
Examples of Damages in Bad Faith Cases
- The unpaid or underpaid benefit amount plus interest from the date of wrongful denial
- Economic losses caused by the delay: unpaid medical bills, wage losses, credit damage, or penalties from other creditors
- Emotional distress, inconvenience, and harm to reputation resulting from the insurer's conduct
- Attorney fees and court costs under Colorado law in successful bad faith claims
- Punitive damages if the insurer's conduct was willful and wanton
Boulder County Justice Center handles these cases, and Colorado law allows recovery of your actual damages plus, in egregious cases, punitive damages to deter similar misconduct by insurers statewide.
What clients say about McCormick & Murphy
Real outcomes and reviews. Check Google reviews for the office that serves Lafayette — and read client testimonials.
After I was hit by a drunk driver with no insurance, my own insurer refused UM benefits. McCormick & Murphy sued for uninsured motorist benefits and bad faith. A jury awarded me over $900,000.
C. O., Denver · UM / bad-faith verdict
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its facts, coverage, venue, and evidence.
Lafayette Insurance bad faith FAQ
What does 'insurance bad faith' mean?
Bad faith means the insurer breached its duty to handle your claim fairly and in good faith. Colorado law requires insurers to investigate, evaluate, and respond to first-party claims promptly and reasonably. Bad faith includes unreasonable delay, denial without a legitimate basis, misrepresenting policy terms, failing to investigate, or refusing to communicate. If the insurer's conduct was unfair or unreasonable, you may have a bad faith claim separate from the underlying claim for benefits.
How do I know if my claim was handled in bad faith?
Bad faith is proven by showing the insurer did not conduct a reasonable investigation, did not communicate with you, delayed payment without justification, denied the claim without a proper basis, or misapplied the policy. We review the insurer's file, internal notes, payment history, and communications obtained during litigation. Common signs include repeated requests for the same documents, missed deadlines for response, vague or changing denial reasons, or unreasonable delays in paying a covered claim. Each case turns on the specific facts and the insurer's conduct.
What deadlines apply to a bad faith claim?
Insurance deadlines depend on the type of policy, the benefit you claimed, and when the insurer's unfair conduct occurred. Generally, a bad faith claim must be filed within the statute of limitations, which is typically two years after the insurer's wrongful conduct becomes apparent. However, your insurance policy may also contain deadlines for filing suit. Preserve your complete claim file and timeline immediately. Contact us as soon as you believe the insurer has delayed or denied your claim unfairly. Do not wait—deadlines apply and missing them may bar your claim.
How is bad faith different from just disagreeing with the claim decision?
An insurer may reasonably deny a claim if the policy does not cover it or if the claim was not properly documented. That is a coverage dispute, not bad faith. Bad faith is different. It means the insurer's conduct in investigating, evaluating, or responding to the claim was unfair, unreasonable, or intentionally designed to avoid payment. We examine whether the insurer had a reasonable basis for its decision and whether it was reached fairly and promptly. If the insurer's explanation does not match the evidence or the investigation was incomplete, bad faith may be present.
How are attorney fees handled in a bad faith case?
McCormick & Murphy handles bad faith claims on a contingency fee basis. We are paid an attorney fee only if your case is settled or won in court. You do not pay us upfront. Advanced case costs—such as expert fees, filing fees, and discovery expenses—are separate from the attorney fee and may be discussed when we review your case. We advance many costs on your behalf, and those are typically recovered from any settlement or judgment, or discussed as part of a fee arrangement. Contact us for details specific to your claim.
Related legal guides
Same service in nearby communities
Nearest McCormick & Murphy office
Discuss your Lafayette claim
Free consultation. No attorney fee unless we recover for you.