Downtown Colorado Springs with Pikes Peak in the background

El Paso County · Homeowner's Insurance

Colorado Springs Dog Bite Insurance Lawyers

Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers for homeowner and renter claims in Colorado Springs. Free consultation. No fee unless we recover for you.

60+years combined experience
El Paso Countylocal bite evidence
929 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905nearest firm office
No feeunless we recover for you

Colorado Springs Dog Bite Insurance Lawyers for Delayed or Denied Claims

McCormick & Murphy are Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers for people whose homeowner or renter insurer delayed or denied a dog-bite claim. We file in El Paso County District Court.

When someone is bitten in Colorado Springs, the money to pay a claim usually comes from the dog owner's homeowner or renter insurance policy, not the owner's personal bank account. That said, we do not tell clients every policy covers dog bites. Coverage depends on the specific policy the owner carries and what that policy says.

Some homeowner and renter policies contain exclusions. An insurer may try to deny coverage based on the breed of dog, a prior bite history, or because the dog was involved in some kind of business use at the time of the incident. Whether an exclusion actually applies is a question of policy language, not a general rule, and we review the actual policy before drawing conclusions.

We look at the owner's coverage early because it shapes how a claim is presented and negotiated. If the owner has no applicable coverage, or coverage is disputed, that changes the path forward and the questions we need to answer before moving ahead.

What We Request From the Insurer Before Accepting a Denial

Once we know which company insures the dog owner, we request the relevant policy and any information the insurer relies on to accept, deny, or delay the claim. We want to see the actual exclusion language an insurer is citing, not just take their word that a bite is not covered. Insurers do not always explain their reasoning clearly on the first pass, and it is worth pushing for specifics.

If a claim is denied or sits without a real response for an extended period, that can raise a coverage question worth examining, and in some cases a separate question about how the insurer handled the claim. We do not assume a denial is made in bad faith just because it is frustrating. We look at what the insurer knew, what it told the claimant, and whether its stated reason holds up against the policy itself.

Investigating Colorado Springs Dog Bite Insurance Claims & Client Office Access

McCormick & Murphy are Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers for people whose homeowner or renter insurer delayed or denied a dog-bite claim.

  • Policy Review Before Accepting Denials: We request the relevant policy and any information the insurer relies on to accept, deny, or delay the claim. We want to see the actual exclusion language an insurer is citing, not just take their word that a bite is not covered.
  • Coverage Varies by Policy Language: Not every homeowner or renter policy covers dog bites. Some policies contain exclusions based on breed, prior bite history, or business use. Whether an exclusion applies depends on the specific policy the owner carries and what that policy says.
  • Office Access: Clients meet with our team at 929 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 ↗ — with home or hospital consultations available if severe injuries prevent travel.
Evidence Checklist Dog Bite Insurance Claim Evidence for Colorado Springs Cases

Documentation to gather when a homeowner or renter insurer has delayed or denied your Colorado Springs dog bite claim. From McCormick & Murphy, Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers serving El Paso County.

  • Name of the dog owner's homeowner or renter insurance company
  • Any letter or written denial the insurer sent
  • Notes on phone calls with the insurer, including names and dates
  • The address where the dog and owner reside
  • Any statement the owner made about having or not having insurance
  • Copy of the actual insurance policy
  • Medical records from the dog bite incident
  • Photos of injuries, scarring, or disfigurement
  • Documentation of lost income from time away from work
  • Scene photos and location details
  • Any information the insurer relies on to deny or delay the claim
  • Records of ongoing or follow-up medical care

Free consultation with Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers at McCormick & Murphy. Call (719) 389-0400. Office at 929 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905. No fee unless we recover for you.

Proof Across Colorado Springs Neighborhoods, From Scene Facts to Policy Review

We work with dog bite claims arising in neighborhoods across the area, including Old Colorado City, Briargate, Broadmoor, Manitou Springs, and Fountain. Homeowner and renter coverage varies by policy regardless of neighborhood, so we review each owner's actual policy rather than assuming what a given area typically carries.

When a coverage dispute cannot be resolved directly with the insurer, litigation may proceed in El Paso County District Court. Our office is located at 929 W Colorado Ave in Colorado Springs, and we meet with clients from around the region to go over what an insurer has said and what the underlying policy actually provides.

Colorado Springs dog-bite overview →

Medical Costs From UCHealth Memorial Hospital Central and Other Losses

Injuries Covered and Excluded Under Homeowner and Renter Policies

When a dog bite happens in Colorado Springs—whether in Old Colorado City, Briargate, Broadmoor, Manitou Springs, or Fountain—the dog owner's homeowner or renter insurance policy is often the first place to turn for compensation. However, not all policies cover all injuries, and some policies contain exclusions that can complicate or block a claim. We help you understand what your policy or the owner's policy actually covers.

Coverage for Bite-Related Medical Expenses

Most homeowner and renter policies include liability coverage that can pay for medical treatment following a dog bite. This typically covers emergency room visits, wound care, infection treatment, and ongoing physician visits at UCHealth Memorial Hospital Central or CommonSpirit Penrose Hospital. The policy's liability limits and deductible structure determine how much is available. If the bite victim has health insurance, the dog owner's policy may pay after the health plan.

Breed and Prior-Incident Exclusions

Many insurers use policy language that excludes dogs of certain breeds, dogs with a documented history of biting, or dogs used for business or guard purposes. The policy language—not Colorado law—controls whether your claim is excluded. An insurer might deny coverage based on these exclusions, even if the dog bite itself caused real injury. Understanding what your policy says about the specific dog is essential.

Scarring, Psychological Injury, and Wage Loss

Beyond immediate medical bills, homeowner and renter policies may also cover damages for scarring, disfigurement, emotional distress, and lost income if the injury prevents you from working. The extent of coverage depends on the policy's liability limits and how the claim is presented to the insurer. Some policies cap certain damages or require proof of economic loss.

Denial and Delay: When Coverage Questions Become a Separate Issue

If an insurer denies your claim or delays investigation without reasonable cause, that handling of the claim itself may become a legal issue separate from the dog bite. A denial based on a policy exclusion may be valid; a denial based on incomplete investigation or improper procedure may not be. We evaluate whether the insurer's response to your claim meets Colorado standards for fair dealing.

Steps to Take Immediately After a Dog Bite in El Paso County

The first hours and days after a dog bite are critical. Your actions—and the information you gather—affect both your health and your ability to build a successful insurance claim. Here's what we advise our clients to do.

  1. Seek Medical Attention Without Delay Go to UCHealth Memorial Hospital Central or CommonSpirit Penrose Hospital, or call 911 if the bite is severe, involves heavy bleeding, or is on the face, hand, or joint. Even seemingly minor bites can become infected or require stitches. A medical record establishes the injury, the date, and the circumstances—all essential to your claim.
  2. Report the Incident to Local Animal Control Contact the Colorado Springs Police Department or El Paso County Animal Control to file a report. Animal control will document the dog, its owner, its vaccination status, and any prior incidents. This official record strengthens your claim and protects public safety.
  3. Collect Names, Contact Information, and Insurance Details Get the dog owner's full name, address, phone number, and email. Ask for their homeowner or renter policy information, including the insurer's name and policy number. If the owner is reluctant, write down any identifying details about the property or vehicle. Photographs of the scene, the dog, and your injury are invaluable.
  4. Document the Scene and Your Injuries Thoroughly Take timestamped photos of the bite wound, the location where the attack occurred, and any property damage. Photograph the dog if safe to do so. Write down everything you remember: time of day, weather, whether the dog was on or off leash, any prior warnings, and any witnesses. Keep this written account dated and detailed.
  5. Preserve All Medical Records and Receipts Keep copies of every emergency department visit, urgent care record, physician note, prescription, and bill related to the bite. Insurance companies will ask for these. Store them in one folder or electronic file, organized by date. This documentation supports both the medical necessity and the damages claimed.
  6. Notify the Dog Owner's Insurance Company in Writing Once you have the policy information, send a written notice to the insurer describing the bite, the date, the location, and your injuries. Keep a copy for your records. This triggers the insurer's obligation to investigate and decide on coverage. Do not accept a quick settlement offer before you fully understand the extent of your injury.

Many dog owners and their insurers will want to resolve the claim quickly. Before accepting any offer, make sure you have finished medical treatment and have a clear picture of your total damages, including scarring, lost wages, and future medical care.

Building an Insurance Claim for Your Dog-Bite Injury

Once you've gathered the essential facts and medical evidence, the next phase is presenting your claim to the dog owner's homeowner or renter insurer—or to your own insurer if the owner is uninsured or if your policy covers incidents in rental properties. We guide you through the documentation and negotiation process.

  1. Organize Your Medical and Economic Evidence Compile your medical records, photographs of the injury at different healing stages, bills and receipts, pay stubs or employer statements showing lost wages, and evidence of scarring or ongoing treatment. Create a summary document that lists each expense, the date, and the amount. Insurance adjusters evaluate claims based on documented costs and losses, so completeness matters.
  2. Understand the Policy Language and Exclusions Request a copy of the dog owner's homeowner or renter policy from the insurer. Read the liability section, the exclusions (especially any breed or prior-bite language), and the limits. If the policy excludes the dog or the type of incident, the insurer may deny the claim. If you disagree with the insurer's interpretation of the policy, we help you challenge that reading.
  3. Submit a Detailed Demand Letter to the Insurer We draft a comprehensive letter describing the incident, the dog owner's responsibility under Colorado law, the nature and extent of your injury, all medical treatment and costs, lost wages or earning capacity, and any permanent effects like scarring. The letter explains how the policy should cover these damages and requests a specific settlement amount. This formal demand starts the negotiation process.
  4. Respond Promptly to Insurer Requests and Provide Requested Records The insurer will likely ask for additional medical records, proof of income loss, photos, or a recorded statement. Provide these promptly and completely. Delays or incomplete responses can slow the claim. If a request seems invasive or unreasonable, we advise you on your rights and whether to comply or object.
  5. Evaluate Settlement Offers and Negotiate or Dispute Unfair Denials The insurer may offer a settlement, deny the claim based on a policy exclusion, or delay while claiming to investigate. We review any offer against the actual damages you've incurred. If the offer is too low or the denial appears unjustified, we negotiate further or advise on legal remedies. Some denials or unreasonable delays can expose the insurer to additional liability.

Insurance claims for dog bites require clear evidence, accurate legal analysis, and persistence in negotiation. The dog owner's insurer may try to minimize or deny the claim. Our role is to ensure your injury and damages are fully documented and properly presented, so the insurer either settles fairly or faces legal pressure to do so. See the dog-bite hub for related claim types. Fatal cases may connect to wrongful death.

How Colorado Law and Insurance Policy Terms Determine Liability

Under Colorado Revised Statutes § 13-21-124, a dog owner is liable for injuries caused by the dog if the injury occurs in a public place or in a lawful private place (including when the victim is at the owner's invitation). The owner is liable even if the dog has no history of violence and even if the owner did not intend harm. This strict liability rule means the insurer cannot escape responsibility by claiming the dog was friendly or never bit before—unless the policy itself excludes the dog or the circumstances.

The homeowner or renter policy is a contract between the owner and the insurer. If the policy language excludes the dog (by breed, prior bite, or other condition), or if the incident falls outside the policy's coverage (for example, if the dog was used for business), the insurer may rightfully deny the claim under the terms of that contract. However, if the insurer denies a claim that should be covered under the policy, or if the insurer delays investigation or mishandles the claim, Colorado law holds the insurer to a standard of fair dealing and timely response. A bad-faith denial or improper delay can result in damages beyond the policy limit.

What clients say about McCormick & Murphy

Real outcomes and reviews. Check Google reviews for the office that serves Colorado Springs — and read client testimonials.

A passenger suffered traumatic brain, neck, and back injuries in a Colorado Springs intersection collision. After the carrier refused a fair number, a jury awarded $295,000 including interest and costs.

El Paso County jury verdict

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its facts, coverage, venue, and evidence.

What Colorado Springs Clients Ask After a Dog Bite or Attack

Do I need Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers after an injury?

Call Colorado Springs dog bite insurance lawyers when you were hurt, fault is disputed, or an insurer delays, denies, or offers less than the medical bills. The Colorado Springs office is at 929 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905.

Does homeowner's insurance always cover a dog bite in Colorado Springs?

Not always. Coverage depends on the specific policy the dog owner carries and whether any exclusion applies. We review the actual policy language rather than assuming coverage exists.

Can an insurer deny a claim because of the dog's breed?

Some policies contain breed-related exclusions, but this depends on the individual policy, not a general rule. We ask the insurer to point to the specific language it is relying on before accepting a denial.

What if the owner says they don't have insurance?

We still gather what information we can about the owner's coverage, since renter policies and other coverage can sometimes apply even when a homeowner policy does not. This is worked out on a case-by-case basis.

Is every claim denial considered bad faith?

No. A denial or delay can raise a legitimate coverage question without amounting to bad faith. We look closely at what the insurer said and whether its reasoning matches the policy before characterizing its conduct.

What happens if the insurer and I can't resolve the claim?

If a resolution can't be reached directly with the insurer, the matter may proceed in court, including El Paso County District Court depending on where the case is filed. We can walk you through what that process involves during a consultation.

Does my homeowner or renter policy automatically cover dog bites?

No. While most homeowner and renter policies include liability coverage, that coverage depends on the specific policy language. Some policies exclude certain breeds, dogs with a prior bite, or dogs used for business. The policy controls. We review your policy to determine whether a bite is covered.

What should I do if the dog owner's insurer denies my claim?

First, ask the insurer in writing why it denied the claim and request the specific policy language it relied on. Review the policy yourself or have us review it. If the denial appears based on a misreading of the policy, or if the exclusion claimed doesn't actually apply, we can challenge the denial in writing or pursue it further. Some denials are valid; others are not.

How long does it usually take to resolve a dog-bite claim with an insurance company?

It depends on the complexity of the injury, the clarity of the evidence, and whether the insurer disputes coverage. Some claims settle within weeks; others take months. If the insurer delays without explanation or denies a claim that should be covered, that delay itself becomes a problem under Colorado law. We monitor the insurer's timeline and push for timely resolution.

If the dog owner doesn't have insurance, can I still recover for my injuries?

Yes. You may pursue a claim directly against the dog owner through a lawsuit. You can also check whether your own homeowner or renter policy covers dog bites from uninsured owners—some policies do. We evaluate all available paths to recovery, including the owner's personal assets and your own coverage.

Nearest McCormick & Murphy office

McCormick & Murphy Colorado Springs — Downtown office location.

Discuss Your Colorado Springs Dog Bite Insurance Case

Speak directly with an experienced injury attorney. Free consultation. No fee unless we win.